Beyond Value Sovereignty
The Problem with Absolutism in the Values and Science Discussion
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.35588/cc.v3i2.5784Keywords:
Values in science, Absolutism, Relativism, Metaphilosophy, Ideal theoryAbstract
The following paper argues that issues in paradigmatic proposals for solving the new demarcation problem stem from absolutist assumptions about judgments of value legitimacy. Both the problem of uninformativeness (Larroulet Philippi 2020; Fernandez-Pinto 2014, 2015) and the problem of ambiguous judgments of cases (Hicks 2014; Intemann 2017) are explained by an absolutist pretension contained in one of the main aims of these proposals: providing criteria for differentiating legitimate from illegitimate uses of values, without qualification. After presenting the problems and showing how they stem from that common source, we will sketch a way forward, inspired mainly by Joseph Rouse’s Beyond Epistemic Sovereignty (1996), advancing routes that can allow philosophers of science to evade these pitfalls and engage with scientific practice in a more salutary manner.
Downloads
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Regarding the copyright of the contributions (i.e. articles or others) published or sent to Culturas Científicas, it will be understood that the authors accept the following terms at the time of submitting:
-
The authors will retain the rights of the contributions they submit to Culturas Científicas.
-
The authors accept that their contribution is subject to the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0) once it is published.
This means that the published contribution may be shared and adapted—even commercially—as long as proper credit is given and no endorsement by the author (i.e. licensor) is implied.
-
Notwithstanding the foregoing, at the time of accepting their contribution, the authors grant its first publication exclusively to Culturas Científicas.
-
Once the contribution is accepted, the authors grant to Culturas Científicas the rights of reproduction and distribution of their article in all countries of the world for their exploitation in any medium, format or support.
-
The authors may adopt other non-exclusive license agreements for the contribution published by our journal (e.g. deposit in archives, publication in other journals, book compendiums or translation) committing to indicate that the original publication was made in Culturas Científicas or publishing the version that already has the identifiers of our journal.
We encourage the authors to spread their articles through the internet in sites designated for it in order to motivate their reading and discussion.
